Beyonce & Shakira - beautiful liar video

The world premiere of Beautiful Liar has arrived. Beyonce and Shakira in one amazing music video, what more could you ask for.

Beyonce ft Shakira - Beautiful

Comments

  1. Brandon
    February 28th, 2007 | 5:36 pm

    yoooooo….this video is hott….definitly shud win video of the year…

  2. February 28th, 2007 | 5:39 pm

    The vid is boring. But when they come together they are like hot twins IMAO

  3. Jemil
    February 28th, 2007 | 5:45 pm

    Love it!! A lethal combination

  4. bb
    February 28th, 2007 | 5:46 pm

    awesome!!!…its incredible the best video ever!! its just so beautiful… they rock!!

  5. gimmy
    February 28th, 2007 | 5:48 pm

    how hot is that?? OMG.. absolutely love it!!!

  6. enuff
    February 28th, 2007 | 5:54 pm

    they look hot in the dance break…

    its two different kinds of sexy

    Beyonce turns up the sexiness
    Shakira is natural with it

    I just don’t like the song.

  7. chase
    February 28th, 2007 | 6:07 pm

    hot hot love it no 1 4 shue

  8. alex
    February 28th, 2007 | 7:11 pm

    OMG shakira looks HOT LOVE HER!! THIS VIDEO IS SEXY AND SUPER HOT
    COL SONG AND VIDEO

  9. J.LoLover
    February 28th, 2007 | 7:37 pm

    Just wait a couple of weeks, and u’ll hear it in every radio station globally, it’s gonna be a very huuuuge hit, Shakira’s super-success of “hips dont lie” is still affecting many countries, and now she is in a world tour. Plus beyonce’s 10 weeks on top of the charts, and her B’Day album reached 4xplatinum, and now she’ll re-release it with spanish songs, she’s gonna conquer the world. maybe some of you havent liked the song, it’s a kind of a song that to get used to, and then the addiction begins, super sexy video, smokin’ hot. am waiting for “upgrade U”, am sure it’a gonna be a sexy video, but am afraid “beautiful liar” will make upgrade U limited, or not famous, am afraid it’s gonna affect it negatively, i dont think releasing 2 videos at the same time is a great idea… but who knows, it might be a mega success.

  10. nisi
    February 28th, 2007 | 7:59 pm

    This is the PERFECT example of Beyonce’s overexposure. She’s put out Deja Vu, Ring the Alarm, Irreplacable, Listen and now Beautiful Liar & Upgrade U within a matter of about 6 months. That’s like a song a month. Isn’t Get Me Bodied coming out soon? This is much too much. She’s gotta pace herself before she runs out of singles and irritates America with Beyonce overload. I don’t really blame her though. I think Pappa Knowles has A LOT to do with it.

  11. Maddox Lenair
    February 28th, 2007 | 8:03 pm

    AMAZING!!! The confusion of their similar beauty is genius!!!! I fuckin’ love this!

  12. February 28th, 2007 | 8:04 pm

    ORGY

  13. February 28th, 2007 | 8:06 pm

    I think they could have don better it kinda reminds me of the “Deja Vu” video with the random scenes!!

  14. Malik
    February 28th, 2007 | 8:14 pm

    ovahnessssssssssssssssssssssssss

  15. Phoenix
    February 28th, 2007 | 9:09 pm

    With Shakira she will reach a broader audience then by herself. She released Beautiful Liar to capture the pop/top40 market, and she released Upgrade U to appeal to the urban market. I think it’s a pretty smart move since she is re-releasing B’Day. Upgrade U will hopefully be popular on the Hip-Hop and R&B charts while Beautiful Liar dominates the Billboard 100.

  16. EBZ
    February 28th, 2007 | 9:36 pm

    Everyone now and then it was hard for me to tell who was who since both got the thick blondish wavy hair going and they are both lightskinned. lol

    song is meh. Video is aight. Don’t get the everyone jump on the latino/latino vibe bandwagon now.

  17. Larry
    February 28th, 2007 | 9:49 pm

    SORRY NISI BUT SHE HAS 8 MORE VIDEOS. MAD MUCH? READY TO PULL YOUR OWN HAIR OUT!!!??

    CAN WE SAY ANOTHER 4 MILLION SOLD PEOPLE..HA HA!!!

  18. casie0803
    February 28th, 2007 | 10:02 pm

    This video was very boring, It seems like Shakira’s style shined in this video, while Beyonce’s style
    took a back seat. The song it’s self is very medicore
    and their voices don’t blend. Bottom line: Beyonce take a 2-year vacation,take some dance classes, get with some good songwriters and come better then this!!If she doesn’t she will suffer overexposure like J.LO.

  19. stevan
    February 28th, 2007 | 10:05 pm

    The video is FANTASTIC!!!So much energy and sex appeal in one place!The song is great!

  20. February 28th, 2007 | 10:56 pm

    EBZ everyone is jumpin on the wagon

  21. truestar
    February 28th, 2007 | 11:27 pm

    wow

  22. February 28th, 2007 | 11:31 pm

    Great video. I was kinda getting confused with who was who at the dance part.

  23. enuff
    February 28th, 2007 | 11:50 pm

    Why do people get caught up with whether a song hits #1 or not? It does not mean that the song is quality. I don’t care if this song hits #1 or not. If it does its no skin off my back. This is Beyonce’ dream that she is following. I got my own goals I am working towards. I just listen to music for hobby and enjoyment. All these comments about another #1 hit are lame and corny unless you are getting a share of the royalties. It figures that some of you joke about this stuff to annoy people and its probably working:).

  24. Jo-E
    March 1st, 2007 | 12:36 am

    I like it but you’re right for those of you that said something about her overexposure. She said on BET that she just shot 8 videos?…For what? Honestly, people including me whom which I am a fan, will get tired of her. Honestly, calm it down.

  25. Iven
    March 1st, 2007 | 2:32 am

    Such a HOTTT vid! But I like the solo version better where B sings by herself,wish Shakira sang in spanish though

  26. BeYonceLicious2
    March 1st, 2007 | 2:39 am

    I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!! I LOVE IT !!!

  27. I can't stand that bitch NISI
    March 1st, 2007 | 2:45 am

    oh well NISI I guess u guna have to cover your eyes and shut your ears casue she has much more to come….what I don’t understand is…. NISI is on every beyonce post and yet she can’t stand her music and etc….I mean NISI, don’t u have a job…or children to mind or even a hobby….maybe jogging…..or maybe painting……maybe even yoga…..but why sit on EVER SINGLE BEYONCE POST…just to exspress your dislike for beyonce………..I see u on every beyonce post and u constantly have summin negative to say….if she so over exsposed….WHY ARE U SUCKIN HER CLIT SO MUCH……..turn ur computer off and throw away the magazine(that u know u bought cause beyonce is on the cover) bitch u need a life…………eveytime sumone say summin bout ur lil XTINA….u jump to defend that frail white bitch……u need some help cause u only on beyonce shit cause u LOVE HER(on the DL)

  28. here we go wit this chick!
    March 1st, 2007 | 6:11 am

    Oh lord here comes “President NISI”…..ya kno what, for sumone who don’t like Beyonce(she has stated so many times)……….YOU(NISI) Is on every single mutha fuckin BEYONCE post(on stars are blind.com)….. and YOU always have summin negative to say about her….neva anything positive(u act like she slept with your man)….I mean don’t u have summin else to do…don’t u have kids or a hobby, maybe even yoga or summin……..u need a fuckin life…..I can’t understand why people who don’t like beyonce(NISI)…..is always on beyonce post(NISI)…..Ranting and Protesting(NISI) about how much they DONT like her(like its really going to change her status as the hottest chick in da game)….its beyond me!…..if u don’t like her, why does she intrest u enough to scroll ur fugly mouse and watch the frickin video just to say she’s over exsposed when YOUR FUCKIN DUMB ASS JUST FUCKIN WASTED 5 MINS ON A SO CALLED “OVER EXSPOSED ARTIST” (who you obvieously find enough intrest in and don’t mind her over exsposure to watch her video and post a comment)…..just addmit it….U LOVE BEYONCE!!!! …….people like u I can’t seem to understand your mentality. u don’t have to like her….she has enough fans….but if u dnt like her then why watch/read/comment/listen/ to her..lmao I don’t understand it….What stupid bitches NISI and all the others are……NISI stick to ur idol that white frail boney fake Marlyn Monroe wanabee XTINA…and leave the BEYONCE(”over exsposed chick”)post alone

  29. melisha
    March 1st, 2007 | 6:20 am

    Lol yes preach that word!!^^^^…………..And that goes for eveybody else who claim she so “over exsposed”. think twice before u click the next beyonce post link, it might jus save u 10 mins of your life then to waste it on a SO CALLED (OVER EXSPOSED CELEBRITY) BEYONCE. Think about that it might jus work, lol cover your eyes and ears cause BEE is here to stay!

  30. Larry
    March 1st, 2007 | 11:13 am

    SAY IT MELISHA…THEY LOVE TO COME ON HERE AND EVERY BEYONCE THREAD COMPLAINING ABOUT HOW TIRED THEY ARE OF HER AND HOW SHE IS OVEREXPOSED. IF YOU FEEL THAT WHY THEN THE THE HELL DO YOU COME TO EVERY BEYONCE POST AND REPLY AND READ. IF YOU TIRED OF HER THEN SKIP THE FUCK OVER HER NAMES THEN. UPGRADE YO GAME AND MOVE THE HELL ON!!!

  31. nisi
    March 1st, 2007 | 11:31 am

    Are you seriously gonna pretend posts 27, 28 and 29 are from three different people. It looks like I have my own fanatic. You’re exactly right. I don’t HAVE to like her. I use too, but not after B’day. These opinions which you take to heart so badly, are my own and I’ll continue to have them.

    Take that stick out your ass and ignore my posts if they aggrivate you so much.

  32. March 1st, 2007 | 7:25 pm

    i love it!!! they really look SOSOSOSOSO much alike!!! itz crazy!!!

  33. ROB
    March 2nd, 2007 | 12:54 am

    2 all da haters etc beyonce isnt overexposed shes jus running shit , ppl cant take dat den das theyre business shes doin her , she aint hating on u (cos u dnt matter)

  34. john
    March 2nd, 2007 | 1:52 am

    Although I feel the song is mediocre, after listening to it a couple of times, I Sort of like it.
    I really would love to see them perform it.

  35. jp
    March 2nd, 2007 | 1:55 am

    well nisi, dis is me. u need ta get a life and leave beyonce alone. u jealous of her. i dont see u singin on tv, sellin records. wut u got? nuthin! beyonce - mucho dinero; you - cero dinero. ha! and i aint even spanish.lol

  36. Marissa
    March 2nd, 2007 | 10:56 am

    That is Nisi’s opinion, you have yours. Not because we think she is overexposed it do’nt mean we hate her or vice versa.Stop being a cock sucker. Athough you are a fan you dont have to love EVERYTHING she does (like her songs and the way she dresses)you idiots. All of her albums with Destiny’s Child and Dangerously Inlove were great albums. But a lot of people including myself did not like the B’day album.But im proud she did it almost by herself. Her song and video with Shakira is not hot. Beyonce looked like Shakira and Shakira looked like Shakira. Face it! It sucked.No one is perfect so don’t expect the very best all the time. But I commend Bee for being her own woman and keep up the good work.

  37. Dale
    March 2nd, 2007 | 10:58 am

    I agree! These girls are cute and talented but the songand video sucked.

  38. Rafael
    March 2nd, 2007 | 11:06 am

    OMG! this video is amazing… the song fit perfectly for them… they look so alike!!! It’s going to be a hit! that’s for sure!! even if it doesn’t reach the 1º spot on Billboard Hot 100! they did it and they did right! unforgetable!!!

    Did anybody see a clip of all the other videos on TRL?????
    OMG! what was that big cat on “Kitty Kat”???? that video is going to be interesting… but not in a good way… hehehehe
    All the other videos look really nice! especially Get Me bodied and Green Light!!! are they all directed by Melina???? and where did Bee find this Melina anyway? I’ve never heard of her! uhauhauhauhua
    I wanted Francis Lawrence or Joseph Khan… but who am I to complain right? uhahuauhuhahuahua

    Go Bee!!!!!!!!

  39. nisi
    March 2nd, 2007 | 11:53 am

    Leave Beyonce alone? What are you? Her dad? She doesn’t know you and you don’t know her. Garunteed, she’s NEVER going to read my posts so what do you care if I write MY OPINIONS about her? And to correct you, I don’t come on every Beyonce thread. Usually I just skim by them because they’re all the same. But if there’s something I wanna say, you can rest assure that I WILL say it. It’s called freedom of speech, people. Look into it.

    JP, I’m glad you finally put your name on something like a MAN who owns up to his opinions. Took you a while, though. I don’t give a damn how much money she makes. Unlike you, and most shallow, superficial Americans, I don’t rate myself on how much money I have. Character, intelligence, creativity, boldness- that’s what’s truly inspires people and B’day has NONE of that. Sure she’s got some good ass-bouncin’ sh*t, like always, but that’s about it. I’d be kissing her ass just as much as you guys are if she SUPRISED me for once instead of following the SAME OL FORMULA.

    I mean, c’mon. Even you crazed fanatics gotta admit this is TOO much. Give America six more months of this OVEREXPOSURE and they’ll be saying the same thing I’ve been saying all along.

  40. indepthinker11
    March 2nd, 2007 | 12:25 pm

    Hi Guys
    This has gotten totally out of hand, on both sides. This woman isn’t thinking about none of you, fan or not. She is trying to get her money, any way she possibly can. Its true she is a lot of hate her way, but she has a lots of fanatics (both are equally sick). If you are going to be a fan, then be a fan of the music, b/c you don’t know her as a person. Also,know that not everybody is going to like her music (ART and OPINION ARE MADE TO CLASH).

    JP, are you saying that if you are not on TV, selling records, sex etc.. Then your nothing? Are you joking?

    How old are you?

    There are many people who are changing the face of this world and women’s rights,there teachers who are helping better our society, who make only 26,000/yr, while entertainers are paid millions of dollars to sing, act, play sports or nothing at all.

    But I guess if you are not on TV,selling records then you’re nothing.

    Have a good day, guys!!

  41. jp
    March 2nd, 2007 | 2:37 pm

    umm, independentthinker, whoeva u is. im not sayin that u shouldnt be hatin cuz u aint got wut she got. and yes im grown. tryna play me? please dont. i will make u look real stupid. and anyway why u hatin on her cuz she gettin hers. ppl pay for entertainment. i guess womens rights, civil rights, etc., aint wut ppl are into. and i hav question for ya’ll haters, if u hate b so much, y u on her page makin immature comments like dat?

  42. jp
    March 2nd, 2007 | 2:39 pm

    and nisi, im through witchu. u stupid.

  43. indepthinker11
    March 2nd, 2007 | 4:50 pm

    From your the way you write, I can tell that you really don’t focus on the world around. Thank you for clarifying that. I really don’t believe you are an adult neither, b/c if you are our school system failed you somewhere. Also, How am I “hatin” on Beyonce, I never said anything about her as person or even her music. If you carefully read my comment again, you will notice that I was addressing her fans and her “haters”. Nothing about my comments where immature or unfocused. Yes, called you out,b/c what you were saying doesn’t make sense,but now I know your don’t posess the intelect required to process a complete thought. Believe me sweety, you will not last a round if you want to match wits(meaning: the basic human power of intelligent thought and perception) with me.

    Have a nice day!!

  44. indepthinker11
    March 2nd, 2007 | 4:59 pm

    I mean:”from the way you write”

  45. shut the hell up everyone
    March 2nd, 2007 | 7:56 pm

    people please! can you stop with the hate? beyonce is one of the greatest performers of our time. and seriously people… think about it.. 8 videos at in 6 months? that is not overexposure! that’s a clever idea. seriously what would happen to the charts if all of beyonce’s songs are hits? it’s a clever plan to ensure that she gets more exposure, which is what every single musician or artist does btw!! and i seriously doubt that people would get sick of beyonce i mean did they get sick of irreplaceable? deja vu? crazy in love? baby boy? some of them songs are old but a lot of people still loving it. and dats a load of crap what some of u haterz say. “i’m over beyonce” blah blah blah! if you really are a fan you can never and will never get over a talent lyk beyonce. either that or u never liked her in the first place and u are guys stirrin the pot cos ya’ll got nothing to do with ya;ll lives!!! stupid idiots… losers… get a life seriously!!!!

  46. enuff
    March 2nd, 2007 | 10:12 pm

    If you are bothered by a simple opinion, then you need to lock yourself up in your room and hide from society because everyone has an opinion and Guess what!!!!—it may not be in agreement with yours.

    If you like these songs, then fine. Stick by your opinion and don’t let others phase you but don’t insult someone (and get all ignant (yes its spelled wrong on purpose))for thinking differently.

    You are not going to keep people from posting so you might as well grow up!!!!!

  47. shut the hell up everyone
    March 3rd, 2007 | 4:55 am

    Hahahaha that’s funny cos i’m pretty sure that i’m not insulting anyone for thinking differently, i’m insulting the people that don’t really quite care about the discussion or topic and just post bullshit to stir the pot as i said before… so get ur facts ryt b4 u start gettin all up in my face.. thanks

  48. Larry
    March 3rd, 2007 | 11:14 am

    YOU PEOPLE DRIVE ME CRAZY. OF COURSE THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO WILL LIKE BEYONCE AND WHO WILL NOT LIKE BEYONCE THATS COOL AND THATS YOUR PROBLEM. FACE IT PEOPLE BEYONCE IS NOT GOING ANYWHERE NO TIME SOON SHE IS HERE TO STAY. SHE IS DOING HER JOB AND SHE IS DOING WHAT SHE LOVES TO DO. SHE’S A NATURAL AT THIS AND IS SUPPOSE TO BE THERE. DON’T HATE ON HER CAUSE SHE CONTINUES TO MAKE MUSIC, MOVIES AND VIDEOS. WHAT’S THE LOGIC OF YOUR HATE? IS IT BECAUSE SHE IS A SUCCESSFUL BLACK WOMAN DOING WHAT SHE LOVES TO DO OR IS IT BECAUSE SHE’S ON TV ALL THE TIME. WELL, IT’S NOT HER FAULT THAT THE MEDIA ETC…LOVES HER!!! CAUSE SHE DOES NOT PAY ANYBODY TO PUT HER ON TV SO DON’T GET MAD AT HER GET MAD AT THE PRODUCTION COMPANIES, TELEVISION STATIONS, RADIO STATIONS ETC…

    NISI ALWAYS COMES ON HERE AND DOWN WHAT SHE DOES AND ETC…BUT I DONT SEE ANYONE ELSE DOING ANYTHING DIFFERENT HONEY. YOUR BELOVED CHRISTINA IS DOING THE SAME ETC…JUST LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE!!! SO DON’T COME ON HERE AND DOWN SOMEONE’S PROFESSION WHEN EVEYONE ELSE IS DOING THE SAME.

    PLUS MARISSA SAID THAT ALOT OF PEOPLE INCLUDING HERSELF DIDNT LIKE B’DAY. WELL TONS MORE LIKE B’DAY AND THAT’S WHY IT WENT TO SALE 4 MILLION PLUS. THAT GOES TO SHOW THAT A FEW HATE ON HER BUT SHE IS LOVED MY MANY MORE. AND TRUST WHEN APRIL 3RD COMES YOU GUYS ARE GONNA DISLIKE HER EVEN MORE BECAUSE THE ALBUM WILL SHOOT BACK UP TO NUMBER 1 AND SHE WILL BE ALL OVER THE TV SCREEN ONCE AGAIN.

  49. Larry
    March 3rd, 2007 | 11:27 am

    I KNOW PEOPLE HAVE OPINIONS OK THATS FINE AND GOOD BUT IF YOU ARE SO TIRED OF BEYONCE AND THINK SHE IS SO OVEREXPOSED THEN WHY THE CONTINUE NEGATIVE COMMENTS ABOUT HER IN EVERY THREAD EVERYDAY? I’M TIRED OF BRITNEY AND HER BULLSHIT AND YOU DON’T SEE ME POSTING IN A THREAD ABOUT HER EVERY 20 MINUTES. I NEED SOMEONE WHO ALWAYS HAVE NEGATIVE THINGS TO SAY ESPECIALLY NISI TO ANSWER THIS ONE QUESTION: IF YOU THINK SHE IS SO OVEREXPOSED AND YOU ARE TIRED OF HER THEN WHY ARE YOU CONSTANTLY ON A THREAD ABOUT HER SPREADING NEGATIVE COMMENTS? WHAT MAKES YOU COME TO THESE THREADS ABOUT HER EVERYDAY AND READ ABOUT HER AND WATCH VIDEOS OF HER IF YOU OR SO TIRED OF SEEING HER ETC… ??

  50. Me
    March 3rd, 2007 | 12:08 pm

    This video proves how sick Beyonce is. For years she has been copying Shakira’s moves and now this. I paused during the dance part and there are places where they use 2 Shakira’s. ust check it out. Besides it’s Beyonces video so her people alter everything to make them look alike. I mean they are actaully like day and night. Beyonce makes me sick and her dance moves look dirty while Shakira’s look natural and innocent, not primitive like B. Poor Shakira for being tricked into Beyonce’s sick ideas.

    And btw Shakira needs to watch out coz there are many cases where some1 copies some1 else and then kills them. Its happens!

  51. marko
    March 3rd, 2007 | 3:34 pm

    Why would Beyonce imitate Shakira moves???They both belly dance,because it goes with the music part!They are both great dancers and singers…No one invented belly dance now,it is oriental dance that exists many centuries ago…And no one is 100% original!If you can do it better please tell me your idea!I love both Beyonce and Shakira!Why are you so obsessed that somebody is copying other???

  52. enuff
    March 3rd, 2007 | 4:20 pm

    Just like some of you feel that people are being redundant with talk of Beyonce being overexposed, Some people are being redundant with talk of Beyonce being the almighty one and the hottest in the game in every post. It can be just as annoying!!!

  53. jp
    March 3rd, 2007 | 11:51 pm

    lol. independentthinker. there is a such thing called short hand. but i guess from your intellect, i’m going to have to break it down for you. i’m sorry if you thought i was calling you immature or whatever, but i was actually gearing it towards all of the haters. and please dont test my wits. you cant handle this. i’m sorry to all of you that are hearing this. i just thought i’d try to keep all the negative comments on b down. it didn’t work and i see that no matter what anybody does or says, there will always be someone who has something negative to say. but anyway, much love to beyonce. let the girl do her thing. reals fans, support her. haters, step! you can’t match b. holla baby!

  54. 1st timer
    March 4th, 2007 | 1:44 am

    omg i totally agree with comment 50.
    Beyonce is always trying to copy shakira.
    At the end of the video it looks like B is trying way too hard and shakira is just doing her natural moves.
    B’s ass is going all over the place. Belly dancing is exotic with smooth moves and it doesnt fit her. Leave the belly dancing to shakira…its just her thing. Shakiras hips dont lie but beyonces DO! ahaha.

  55. Me
    March 4th, 2007 | 5:57 am

    I don’t like that Beyonce copies Shakira because Shakira is unique, and although I know Beyonce will never measure up to her, Its still irritating. Beyonce even had the audacity to say on TRL that she and Shakira look alike, I mean Shakira has white skin and beyonce is black. Beyonce buys a weave that kinda looks like Shakira’s hair and convices Shakira that they should wear the same clothes in the video. Beyonce’s video crew makes the shots so unclear so that they can look alike. Take a picture of Shakira and one of Beyonce and ull see they look completely different. The lips the eyes, the nose, they are completely different. So how can Beyonce say they look alike. Their bodies are so different too.

    Look at this link:
    http://www.latingossip.com/latin-gossip/beyonce-copies-shakira.html

    There is your proof. Beyonce is disturbed.

  56. Me
    March 4th, 2007 | 6:57 am

    Oh and to the person who said Beyonce and Shakira both bellydance, You are making a huge mistake. Shakira bellydances but Beyonce ASS-DANCES. Beyonce couldnt bellydance no matter how much she tries. Shakira can do it because she is half Lebanese. Have u seen how she moves her stomach muscles? That is bellydancing, not “popping” your booty like Beyonce does.

  57. Larry
    March 4th, 2007 | 12:39 pm

    @ ME…PLEASE NO IS IMPRESSED BY YOUR PIECE OF SHIT LINK THAT YOU PUT UP. PEOPLE HAVE BEEN BELLYDNCING FOR YEARS WAY BEFORE SHAKIRA WAS EVEN IN EXISTENCE. PICK UP THE HISTORY BOOKS AND GO BACK AND LOOK AT WHERE BELLYDANCING ORIGINATED FROM AND THEN COME ON HERE AND TALK CRAP. CAUSE PEOPLE SUCH AS JOSEPHINE BAKER, DOROTHY DANDRIDGE, PEOPLE IN JAMAICA AND HAWAII ETC…AND AS RECENT AS AALIYAH USE TO BELLYDANCE ALOT BEFORE SHAKIRA, SO DON’T TRY TO MAKE IT SEEM LIKE SHAKIRA ORIGINATED IT CAUSE SHE COPPING FROM THE PAST JUST LIKE BEYONCE.

    PEOPLE KILL ME JUST BECAUSE BEYONCE DID SOME DANCE MOVES LIKE SOMEONE ELSE NOW SHE HAS TO COPY. THERE’S NOTHING ORIGINAL ABOUT SHAKIRA JUST LIKE BEYONCE THEY BOTH USE THE PAST AND REBIRTH DANCE MOVES, MUSIC ETC…SO KEEP HATING CAUSE IT ONLY MAKES BEYONCE A BIGGER HOUSEHOLD NAME THAN WHAT SHE ALREADY IS!!!!!

  58. March 4th, 2007 | 1:03 pm

    I WAS TOLD THIS PHRASE WHEN I WAS A LIL KID AND IN BEYONCE CASE IT’S TOTALLY TRUE…

    “WHEN PEOPLE START TO HATE YOU AND FIND ANYTHING NEGATIVE OR WRONG TO SAY ABOUT YOU, THAT MEANS YOU DOING SOMETHING RIGHT”

    HA! SO TRUE!!

  59. jp
    March 4th, 2007 | 2:10 pm

    i think beyonce is sexier than shakira and danced better than her in the video. beyonce is herself. she dont copy nobody, she was jus tryin sumthin new. beyonce is curvier and sexier than shakira. shakira got it goin on too, im not hatin, im jus sayin that b is the best!

  60. Me
    March 4th, 2007 | 3:39 pm

    Firstly Larry let me clear something up for you. Bellydancing has never been performed by Jamaicans or Hawaiians and definately not by Aaliyah! Bellydancing originated either in Phoenicia (modern day Lebanon) or Egypt and is performed in Eastern Europe and the Middle East. Hawaiians do Hoola or whatever they do. amaicans do some type of tribal African thing. Blleydancing is an erotic dance that requires that you move your abdominal muscles in a smooth sensual way. Not in a hard, disgusting way like Beyonce. And I am from Africa dude, and let me tell you. Africans cannot bellydance. Look at how calmly Shakira moves and it looks hot, but Beyonce looks like she is constipated, whoever said that is correct. it does not look right. Aaliya just wore clothes that revealed her stomach, she never bellydanced, never ever!
    And Beyonce never ever moves her “belly” she popps her butt. You are really being rediculous if you think that what Beyonce does or ever did is bellydancing. Come on! Have u seen Shakira’s whenever wherever video? There u can clearly see bellydancing. When it looks almost like she is inflating her belly with air and then deflates it. She isnt really inflating it, its ust the muscles relaxing and tightening. That is bellydancing, not shaking your hips or popping your back.

    And Shakira has been bellydancing since she was a child, it is part of her Lebanese culture, she is not copying any1 else.

    Beyonce needs help because she obviously doesnt like herself very much thats why she is copying Shakira, and Larry Beyonce has never done anything right haha thats a joke, coz Beyonce is a oke

  61. Larry
    March 4th, 2007 | 6:30 pm

    LIKE I SAID SHAKIRA DID NOT AND I REPEAT DID NOT ORIGINATE “BELLYDANCING”. SO DON’T ACT LIKE SHE IS NOT COPPING FROM DECADES AND CENTURIES WHEN WOMEN BELLYDANCED. HAWAIIAN’S DOES DO HOOLA WHICH IF YOU REALLY KNEW YOUR FACTS IS ANOTHER FORM, ANOTHER ART OF BELLYDANCING. AND LOOK AT PERFORMACES OF AALIYAH PERFOMANCES AND VIDEO’S AND TELL ME THAT SHE’S NOT BELLY DANCING IN MOST OF HER VIDEO’S. SHE HAS PLENTY OF INTERVIEWS TEACHING PEOPLE HOW TO DO IT AND CALLED IT HER “SIGNATURE” MOVE. IM NOT SAYING THAT SHAKIRA COPIED OFF AALIYAH BUT IM SIMPLY STATING THAT THERE WERE OTHER PEOPLE DOING THE SAME DANCES WAY BEFORE SHAKIRA SO DONT MAKE IT SEEM LIKE SHAKIRA IS THE ONLY PERFORMER THAT HAS DONE DANCING MOVES. SHAKIRA POPS HER ASS JUST LIKE THE REST OF US SO PLEASE SIT DOWN WITH THE BULLS*IT.

    OBVIOUSLY BEYONCE IS DOING SOMETHING RIGHT IF PEOPLE LIKE YOU HATE ON HER BECAUSE OF HER TALENT. I ADMIT THAT BEYONCE DOES DO DANCES THAT EVERYONE CAN DO BUT DONT LACK THE TALENT AND THE VOICE PLAYA. WHY DO U THINK SHE HAS 156 AWARDS IN HER HOME BECAUSE SHE HAS PURE TALENT. WHY DO YOU THINK SHE HAS MILLIONS OF FANS THAT LOVE AND ADORE HER BECAUSE OF HER TALENT AND HER BEING A HUMBLE INDIVIDUAL. PLUS SHE CAN SING WITH THE BEST OF THEM SO FOR YOU TO SAY BEYONCE IS A JOKE IS MAKING YOU LOOK LIKE ONE.

    HA!

  62. Me
    March 5th, 2007 | 7:33 am

    Larry you still don’t get it, you don’t understand what the term bellydancing means. Hoola is not a form of bellydancing, the 2 are not related. They may move their hips but it is not bellydancing. And Aaliyah also moved her hips slowly side to side, she never moved her BELLLLLLLYYYYYYYYY! Shakira is the only “celebrity” who actually bellydances, the ancient form of dance that her ancestors did, shes not copying because it is within her. She is the only celeb who moves her belly don’t u get it? She has done it since she was a child. It’s not a tribal dance like the Hawaiians. It’s a dance done for the royal men in eastern Europe and the Middel East.

    And Larry I don’t hate Beyonce. I just think she has issues because she is so fake. She should be proud of being a black woman, but she isn’t. She has never appeared without a weave and now she claims she looks like Shakira, a white woman (and Shakira is a white woman for those of you who don’t know there are white people in Latin America). I want Beyonce to be herself. The way she was before Shakira crossed over into the American market. When she never tried to be like Shakira. And I also want Shakira to go back to the days when she made Rock music. All Shakira’s fans are upset about this. Beyonce is using Shakira because Beyonce hates herself!!!!

    I liked Beyonce when she herself, now she wants to copy Shakira and the fact of life is, u will only ever be great if you are yourself, u will never match up to the person you are copying.

  63. March 5th, 2007 | 2:56 pm

    YOU SOUND LIKE A BUNCH OF BULL. YOU DONT KNOW WHAT BEYONCE FEELS INSIDE ABOUT HERSELF. YOU DON’T IF BEYONCE LIKES HERSELF OR NOT, YOU DON’T KNOW THAT WOMAN AND YOU DON’T EVEN KNOW SHAKIRA SO DON’T MAKE STATEMENTS LIKE THAT UNLESS YOU KNOW THESE LADIES PERSONALLY. JUST BECAUSE SHE DOES SOME DANCES MOVES LIKE SOMEONE ELSE DOES NOT MEAN SHE DISLIKE HERSELF. LISTEN TO YOURSELF!! OK SO MY COUSIN HAD ON A PAIR OF BOOTS THAT I LIKED AND I WENT AND BOUGHT ME THE SAME PAIR. SO BASICALLY I DONT LIKE MYSELF BECAUSE I BOUGHT ME A PAIR OF BOOTS THAT SOMEONE HAD ON THAT I LIKED. IT SOUNDS THE SAME TO ME!!

    BEYONCE WASN’T TRYING TO BE SHAKIRA IN 2003 WHEN DIL CAME OUT AND SHE’S CERTAINLY NOT TRYING TO BE LIKE HER NOW. WHEN SHE SAID THAT THEY KINDA LOOK ALIKE. SHE MEANT THE KIND OF PERFORMANCES AND DANCE STYLES THAT THEY DO AND SOMETIMES THE WAY THEY WEAR THEIR HAIR. EVERY WOMAN IN HOLLYWOOD WEARS EXTENSIONS AND WEAVE’S NOW. SORRY TO TELL YOU BUT EVEN SHAKIRA WEARS EXTENSION’S BUDDY. YOU SAID YOU WANT BEYONCE TO BE HERSELF BEFORE SHAKIRA CAME OUT. WELL BEYONCE STILL DID THE SAME DANCES AND STILL WORE WEAVE AND MADE THE SAME TYPE OF MUSIC BEFORE SHAKIRA CAME OUT SO I DONT SEE WEAR YOUR GETTIN THIS FROM.

  64. March 5th, 2007 | 3:06 pm

    @ ME…IM DONE WITH IT. YOU BELIEVE WHAT YOU WANT TO BELIEVE AND YOU WILL CONTINUE TO WATCH THE WORLD WIDE SUCCESS THAT BEYONCE IS HAVING CAUSE IT’S GOING NOWHERE AND SHE’S GOING NO WHERE. IF SHE’S COPYING SHAKIRA LIKE YOU WANT TO BELIEVE THAT SHE IS THEN SHE’S DOING A GOOD DAMN JOB OF IT.

  65. March 5th, 2007 | 3:23 pm

    ONE MORE THING, THIS IS THE LAST ONE BUT THIS JUST POPPED IN MY HEAD…

    I WANT ALL THE PEOPLE THAT FEEL THAT BEYONCE IS COPYING SHAKIRA, ESPECIALLY “ME” TO ANSWER THIS ONE…

    WHY WOULD YOU THINK SHAKIRA WOULD AGREE TO DO A VIDEO AND A SONG WITH BEYONCE IF SHE FELT THAT BEYONCE IS COPYING HER STYLE? OBVIOUSLY SHAKIRA DOESN’T FEEL THIS WAY OTHERWISE SHE WOULDN’T HAVE AGREED TO DO IT!!!

    SO PLEASE ANSWER THAT!!!!

    P.S. PLEASE DON’T SAY IT’S BECAUSE SHAKIRA HAS A BIG HEART OR BECAUSE IT WAS FOR MONEY CAUSE SHAKIRA HAS PILES OF MONEY AND ANYBODY’S REPUTATION/IMAGE IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN MONEY.

  66. Me
    March 5th, 2007 | 4:46 pm

    I will answer your last question Larry! Shakira agreed for a couple of reasons.
    1) Beyonce told the media about the duet before Shakira agreed. So she would come off badly if she didn’t.
    2) Shakira might not know Beyonce has been copying her because you might not know this, but Beyonce isn’t very popular outside the US and Skaira spends most of her time in Europe and Latin America plus shes very busy.
    3) Shakira might be flattered by Beyonce copying her.
    4)Shakira would know how ridiculous Beyonce’s copying is and she knows Beyonce is no threat to her because the reality is that they are so different.
    I am going to have all Shakira’s supporters start a campaign against Beyonce. For the sake of Shakira’s didgity. All Shakira’s fans are outraged that she would duet with a shallow no-talent, unoriginal person, like Beyonce. And don’t Beyonce can sing, coz she has a whiney voice and cant hold a strong constant note like Shakira. And if you disagree, watch Shakira’s unplugged Spanish video or listen to the CD

  67. LARRY
    March 5th, 2007 | 6:33 pm

    YOU ARE THE FUNNIEST PERSON EVER. IF BEYONCE IS NOT POPULAR OUTSIDE OF THE US THEN WHY IN THE HELL HER CONCERTS ARE ALWAYS SOLD OUT OVERSEAS. CHECK THE FACTS MAN CAUSE YOU REALLY SOUND CRAZY RIGHT NOW. GO BACK AND CHECK WHEN SHE HAD HER TOUR IN JAPAN, EUROPE, ETC… YOU KNOW WHAT THIS IS WHY IM DONE DEBATING WITH YOU CAUSE YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT. WHY WOULD SHE GO ON NATIONAL TV AND SAY SHE IS DOING A DUET WITH SOMEONE IF IT IS NOT FINAL. SHE COULD GET SUED FOR THAT. COME ON NOW YOU SOUND ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS!!!!!

    AND WHAT IS YOUR STUPID CAMPAIGN GONNA DO? MAKE HER AN EVEN MORE BIGGER STAR THAN WHAT SHE IS? COME ON NOW PEOPLE LIKE YOU TRIED TO DO THE “DEJA VU” VIDEO CAMPAIGN AND WHAT DID IT DO, NOTHING BUT JUST MADE “DEJA VU” AN INTERNATIONAL HIT.

    IF BEYONCE IS NOT KNOWN OVERSEAS THEN WHY WAS “IRREPLACEABLE” #1 IN 10 COUNTRIES. SHAKIRA HAS NOTHING TO WORRY ABOUT AS DOES BEYONCE CAUSE BOTH OF THEM ARE VERY TALENTED PERFORMER/SINGERS AND SELLS MILLIONS EACH.

    JUST LIKE YOU SAID ALOT OF SHAKIRA FANS ARE MAD, WELL ALOT OF BEYONCE FANS ARE MAD BECAUSE SHE DID A SONG WITH SHAKIRA THAT SOUNDS LIKE A DAMN HYENA GETTING CHOCKED…LOL…I DONT FEEL THAT WAY BUT ALOT OF BEYONCE FANS DO.

  68. Larry
    March 5th, 2007 | 8:29 pm

    ARE YOU SERIOUS? EVERY CONCERT THAT BEYONCE HAS DONE OVERSEAS HAS BEEN SOLD OUT. IRREPLACEABLE WAS #1 IN 10 COUNTRIES AND YOU GOT THE NERVE TO SAY THAT SHE’S NOT POPULAR OVERSEAS…HA…EVERY CONCERT IN EUROPE AND JAPAN ETC…HAS BEEN SOLD OUT. PLEASE GET YOUR FACTS STR8 CAUSE YOU SOUND RIDICULOUS!!!!!

    AND WHAT IS YOUR STUPID LIL CAMPAIGN GONNA DO, NOTHING BUT MAKE HER AN EVEN BIGGER STAR THAN WHAT SHE IS. YOU THE SAME PEOPLE THAT TRIED TO DO THE “DEJA VU” CAMPAIGN AND IT DID NOTHING BUT MADE “DEJA VU” AN INTERNATIONAL HIT!!!

    WHY WOULD SHE GO ON NATIONAL TV AND SAY THAT SHE IS DOING A DUET WITH SOMEONE IF SHE IS NOT SURE. YOU CAN DO THAT BECAUSE YOU CAN GET SUED FOR DOING THAT. COME ON NOW!!!

    ALOT OF BEYONCE FANS ARE MAD THAT SHE DID A SONG AND VIDEO WITH SOMEONE WHO SOUNDS LIKE A DAMN HYENA GETTING CHOCKED. I DON’T FEEL THAT WAY BUT ALOT OF BEYONCE FANS DO.

    THE POINT IS THAT THEY ARE FRIENDS AND THAT ADMIRE EACH OTHER’S CAREER’S. SHARIKA HAS BEEN ON RECORD WITH SAYING HOW MUCH SHE LIKES BEYONCE AND VISE VERSA. YOU PEOPLE KILL ME BECAUSE YOU ALWAYS TRYING TO MAKE SOMETHING POSITIVE INTO A NEGATIVE CAUSE YOUR LIVES ARE FULL OF NEGATIVITY. WHY CAN’T YOU JUST ACCEPT THAT THEY ARE MAKING GREAT MUSIC AND VIDEOS AND ARE TRYING TO APPEAL TO EACH OTHERS FAN BASE AND I THINK IT IS WORKING AND I CANT WAIT WHEN PEOPLE LIKE YOU FELL SO DUMB AND STUPID WHEN THIS BECOMES A HUGE HIT.

  69. shut the hell up everyone
    March 6th, 2007 | 5:17 am

    amen larry!! testify ma brudda!! way to kick them haters to the gutter where they belong!!! lol

  70. Me
    March 6th, 2007 | 7:19 am

    Larry go to Shakiramedia.com. Look in the Videos archive. Beyonce had an interview last year where she talked about the duet and how she hoped Shakira would say yes. And Beyonce is known outside the US but she is definately not HUGE like Shakira, shes just another singer. I have nothing against Beyonce but I ust don’t like unoriginal people. I’m a musician myself and I know Shakira is unique and she writes all her own music, unlike Beyonce, that is why I respect her. Oh and another thing, why did Beyonce release a spanish version of Irriplaceable? Coz she wants to be like Shakira, but the song flopped because she doesnt realise that Shakira is a rock star ouside the US and not an RnB star. that is why Shakira’s fans are upset not with Beyonce, but with Shakira because she never released the good songs on her album, just crap like HDL that wasn’t even on her album. Shes been reduced to a hip shaker and shes more than that. It’s pressures from people in the US that has made her do this, but the truth is she needs to realise that she doesnt even need the support of the US if they don’t like her for her music because Don’t bother didnt do too good, then HDL came. But anyway, Beyonce is just an idiot, my beef isnt with her.

  71. March 6th, 2007 | 5:26 pm

    everyone could stop hating on bee. she does her own thing that another bitch in the came can’t do. she talented people lets face it everytime the women does something the media and society has to find something wrong with it. but y’all hating keeps Bee tall why do you think she never complains. True queens and kings are never just excepted. get my drift….

  72. MELISHA
    March 7th, 2007 | 2:15 am

    woooooooooow “ME” i find it funny thAT U COME UP WITH ALL THESE WRONG FACT ABOUT BEYONCE BITCH U ARE SOOO WRONG, I SEE U BEEN RESEARCHIN THE WRONG SHIT BITCH, U NEED TO SIT DOWN IN THE CORNER SUMWHERE….ANYWAY IM TRYIN TO UNDERSTAND WHY ALL THESE PEOPLE WHO DONT LIKE BEYONCE ARE DOIN ALL THESE PRECHIN LIKE ANYBODY IS GUNA ACTUALLY CARE…LMAO SHARKIRA CANNOOOOOOOT SING and I DUNNO WHY BEYONCE DID THAT DUET WITH THAT HALF DEAD CAT…. ALLIYAH BEEN DOIN THAT BELLY DANCE SHIT FOR AGES NOW BEFORE SHAKIRA…..AND I THINK BEYONCE LOOK 10 TIMES BETTER THAT SHAKIRA IN THAT VIDEO…AND TO NISI I DONT UNDERSTAND THAT BITCH FOR NOTHING….SHE ALWAYS ON BEYONCE CLIT AND CLAIM SHE CANT STAND HER BUT SHE ALWAYS HERE LISTENIN AND WATCHIN AND COMMENT ON A CHICK SHE DONT EVEN LIKE…WHAT A WAY TO WASTE YA LIFE BITCH….FIND YASELF A HOBBY……YOU PEOPLE ARE SOOOOOO LAME BEYONCE IS HOOOOOOOOOOT FOREVER AND SHE NOT GOIN NOWHERE…..AND THE BEYONCE IS WAAAAAAY BIGGER INTERNATIONAL THAN NATIONAL….CAUSE AMERICANS ARE SOOO FUCKIN JEALOUS ABOUT WHAT THE OTHER PERSON HAS AND CONSTANTLY HATE ON EACH OTHER……LASTLY NISI LOVES CHRISTINA BUT THAT CHICK IS WORST THAT BEYONCE….SHE SELLS SEX 247 …..IF NOT FOR HER GETTIN NAKED ON MAGAZINES AND ON CD COVERS NOBODY WOULD CARE FOR HER CAT SCREAM VOICE…….SO NISI NEXT TIME U TALK SHIT ABOUT BEYONCE ANALIZE YA LIL MAROLYN MONROE WANA BE AND TALK ABOUT UNORIGINALTY THEN….CAUSSE SHE IS DOWN MAROLYNS THROAT…..BUT NOBODY DONT SEE THAT RIGHT>>>..LOLOLOLOLOL

  73. Me
    March 7th, 2007 | 7:33 am

    Melisha you are just showing how stupid you are. I am not from America so I would